Updated June 2026

Best Storm & Hail Damage Roofing Contractors in Indianapolis

The 6 best storm & hail damage roofing contractors serving Indianapolis, IN — independently researched and ranked. No paid placements.

Storm and hail damage roofers in Indianapolis handle emergency repairs, insurance-claim documentation, and full roof restoration after severe weather. The 6 contractors below were selected from our full Indianapolis top 10 as the strongest for storm & hail damage work, ranked by experience, manufacturer certifications, BBB standing, and verified reputation.

Indianapolis and the Central Indiana metro experience a storm season that routinely produces damaging hail and straight-line wind events from April through September. Marion County's mix of early-twentieth-century Meridian-Kessler bungalows, mid-century ranch homes in Lawrence and Speedway, and newer subdivisions in Fishers and Greenwood presents contractors with a wide range of roof ages — many of the older properties carry shingles at or beyond their design life when a hail event becomes the trigger for an insurance replacement that would have been warranted on age alone. Understanding this distinction — storm damage versus age-related failure — is important for Indianapolis homeowners navigating the claim process.

Indiana's absence of a statewide roofing licence shifts verification to Marion County's local contractor licensing framework through the Department of Business and Neighborhood Services, and to the insurance and bonding documentation that storm-damage contractors are expected to carry. Indianapolis's storm seasons draw out-of-state crews after major events, making the screening process more important than in quieter markets. HAAG certification among inspectors and documented Central Indiana project history are the most reliable local quality signals when evaluating storm-damage contractors after a significant hail or wind event affects the metro.

Quick Comparison

Rank Company Specialty Experience BBB Website
1 Amos Exteriors, Inc. Best Overall Since 1971 A+ Accredited Visit
2 Sherriff-Goslin Roofing Best for Storm & Hail Damage Since 1906 Visit
3 Moss Roofing Best Family-Owned Since 1991 Visit
4 Watertight Roofing & Construction Best for Insurance Claims Since 1939 A+ Accredited Visit
5 Stay Dry Roofing Best for Residential Replacement Since 2016 A+ Accredited Visit
6 Indy Roof & Restoration Best for Storm Restoration Since 2018 A+ Accredited Visit

Detailed Reviews

#2

Sherriff-Goslin Roofing

Best for Storm & Hail Damage
ExperienceSince 1906 (115+ Years)
BBB Status
SpecialtyResidential & Commercial Roofing
Service AreaIndianapolis & the Midwest

With company roots tracing to 1906, Sherriff-Goslin is one of the oldest roofing names in the Midwest and operates a dedicated Indianapolis branch. The company is known for its patented interlocking Art-Loc shingle, which forms a distinctive diamond pattern, and serves homeowners and insurance providers across the metro with shingle and commercial roofing systems.

Roof Replacement Roof Repair Art-Loc Shingle Roofing Storm Damage Repair Commercial Roofing Roof Inspections
Visit Sherriff-Goslin Roofing
#3

Moss Roofing

Best Family-Owned
ExperienceSince 1991 (30+ Years)
BBB Status
SpecialtyResidential & Commercial Roofing
Service AreaIndianapolis, Greenwood & Brownsburg

Founded by Beverly and Steve Moss in 1991 and still run by the founding family, Moss Roofing is a GAF Master Elite Contractor, a distinction held by only a small fraction of contractors nationwide. The company provides residential repairs and full replacements, storm damage repair, commercial roofing, attic insulation, siding and gutters across the south and west sides of the metro.

Roof Replacement Roof Repair Storm Damage Repair Commercial Roofing Attic Insulation Gutters Siding
Visit Moss Roofing
#4

Watertight Roofing & Construction

Best for Insurance Claims
ExperienceSince 1939 (80+ Years)
BBB StatusA+ Accredited
SpecialtyResidential & Commercial Roofing
Service AreaIndianapolis & Central Indiana

Operating since 1939, Watertight Roofing brings more than 80 years of experience to the Indianapolis area and emphasizes storm and insurance work. The company carries HAAG Certified Inspector and IICRC firm credentials and is part of the Property Loss Appraisal Network, alongside an A+ BBB rating, handling roofing, gutters, siding, windows and storm damage repair for residential and commercial clients.

Roof Replacement Roof Repair Storm Damage Repair Gutters Siding Window Replacement
Visit Watertight Roofing & Construction
#5

Stay Dry Roofing

Best for Residential Replacement
ExperienceSince 2016 (8+ Years)
BBB StatusA+ Accredited
SpecialtyResidential & Commercial Roofing
Service AreaIndianapolis Metro

Established in 2016, Stay Dry Roofing is a GAF Master Elite Contractor with an A+ BBB rating and a Google Guaranteed badge, focused on residential roof replacement and repair across the Indianapolis metro. The company also offers commercial flat-roof systems including TPO, EPDM and PVC, plus roof coatings, gutters, siding and storm damage restoration.

Roof Replacement Roof Repair Emergency Tarping Commercial Flat Roofing Gutters Siding Storm Damage Restoration
Visit Stay Dry Roofing
#6

Indy Roof & Restoration

Best for Storm Restoration
ExperienceSince 2018 (6+ Years)
BBB StatusA+ Accredited
SpecialtyResidential & Commercial Restoration
Service AreaIndianapolis & Central Indiana

Established in 2018, Indy Roof & Restoration is an Owens Corning certified contractor and Malarkey roofing partner with an A+ BBB rating (accredited since 2019). The company focuses on storm, hail and wind damage restoration and insurance-claim assistance, alongside residential and commercial roofing, gutters, siding, water and fire restoration across 30-plus Central Indiana cities.

Roof Replacement Roof Repair Storm & Hail Damage Metal Roofing Gutters Siding Water & Fire Restoration
Visit Indy Roof & Restoration

When Central Indiana's Hail and Windstorm Seasons Drive Indianapolis Roof Replacements

After a Hail Event Has Affected Your Marion County Neighborhood

Hail in Indianapolis can be highly localized — cells that produce coin-sized or larger hail over one neighborhood may produce no damage three blocks away. After a verified storm event, a prompt inspection establishes the damage condition before subsequent weather cycles obscure impact evidence. Timely filing also matters because Indiana insurance policies carry reporting requirements that, if missed, can complicate settlement.

When Wind Has Displaced Shingles or Damaged Ridge and Hip Sections

Straight-line wind events in the Indianapolis area frequently produce tab-level shingle displacement and ridge cap blow-offs across entire roof sections. Apparent displacement that is pressed back into position by wind reversal can leave the seal strip broken, which allows water infiltration at the next rain event. A thorough storm-damage assessment checks seal integrity across the entire field, not just visibly displaced sections.

For Claim Documentation That Keeps Pace With HAAG-Familiar Adjusters

Indianapolis insurance adjusters processing storm claims in a busy season use structured assessment protocols. A contractor who employs HAAG-certified inspectors or who has extensive documentation experience in the Central Indiana market can produce written damage assessments that speak the same technical language. This alignment typically leads to more complete settlements than assessments prepared without adjuster-workflow experience.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many storm & hail damage roofing contractors are in Indianapolis?

Our directory lists 6 independently verified storm & hail damage roofing contractors serving Indianapolis, Indiana, ranked by experience, certifications and reputation. Amos Exteriors, Inc. is ranked #1. There are no paid placements.

How do I choose a storm & hail damage roofer in Indianapolis?

Confirm licensing and insurance for Indiana, ask for storm & hail damage project references in Indianapolis, get multiple written quotes, and check each contractor's BBB standing. Every company listed here has been independently researched.

Does Indianapolis require a contractor licence for storm-damage roofing?

Marion County requires a local contractor licence issued by the Department of Business and Neighborhood Services for roofing work that requires a permit. Because Indiana does not license roofers at the state level, this local licence is the primary credential to verify. Request the contractor's Marion County registration and confirm it is current before signing any storm-damage authorization.

How do I tell the difference between storm damage and age-related shingle wear in Indianapolis?

Storm damage typically presents with consistent impact patterns distributed across the roof surface in a directional pattern matching the storm's approach, along with concurrent damage to soft-metal targets like gutters and vent caps. Age-related wear shows irregular granule loss concentrated on south-facing slopes, with no corresponding soft-metal impact evidence. A HAAG-certified inspector can distinguish these patterns and document the finding in a format that Indiana adjusters recognize.

Are there Indianapolis-specific risks with out-of-state storm chasers?

Yes. Storm chasers who appear in Indianapolis after major events frequently lack Marion County contractor registration, carry minimal local insurance, and may not be available for warranty claims once they leave the market. Indiana does not have a specific storm-chaser statute, so screening falls to the homeowner. Confirming a permanent Central Indiana business address, local licence, and BBB standing before signing any authorization is the most effective protection.

Storm Damage Guides

Other Roofing Specialties in Indianapolis